Dauphin Island, AL
Archive of Historical Data, Books, Maps
And Other Materials
How Admiral Farragut got whipped
in the first Battle of Mobile Bay: opinion
By: Mike Marshall, Mobile, AL
Posted online AL.com,July 31, 2014
As we gather this weekend to commemorate the Union
capture of Mobile Bay, let's likewise celebrate an earlier siege of our bay's Confederate fortifications.
This little known campaign also lasted a few weeks, but ended when Admiral David G. Farragut's fleet
turned tail and steamed back to their home bases. The engagement has been painstakingly documented
and illustrated by Mobile attorney, author and historian Sid Schell, who died this past June.
What Fort Powell would have looked like,
drawn by author and historian Sidney Schell, and included in his book.
Photo by AL.com from Schell's book
According to Sid's meticulous research: The first Battle of Mobile Bay occurred in the winter
of 1864, some seven months before the Yankees attacked Fort Gaines and Fort Morgan. Farragut originally
tried to breach the bay's defenses through its western approach, from the Mississippi Sound side of
Dauphin Island, defended by valiant Fort Powell and satellite gun batteries at Cedar Point and
Little Dauphin Island.
Imagine the main defense, Fort Powell, built on sand piled onto a shallow oyster reef then located
about where the middle of Dauphin Island Bridge is now. Imagine the smaller gun batteries placed near
the terminal points of today's Dauphin Island Bridge, one at Cedar Point on the mainland, and one
on Little Dauphin Island, the first solid ground you reach as you approach the island.
Together, these fortifications were built to keep the Union from entering Mobile Bay from the west.
Manning Fort Powell was the 21st Alabama, comprised of the Mobile Battle Guards, the Mobile
Cadets and the South Carolina Battery, all under the command of Lt. Col. James Williams of Mobile.
At 9 a.m. on Feb. 15, 1864, Union mortar boats opened fire on Fort Powell. Shortly after they started their
bombardment, Williams wrote to his wife in Mobile: "I have been longing for such a fight as I now have on my
hands for a long time, and expect to have an interesting time of it."
For the next 15 days, that flotilla as well as reinforcements from Pensacola attempted to hammer the
fortifications on the west side. They struggled to aim their guns in the cold north wind, but made little
headway as Fort Powell and her outposts returned fire.
The Union lobbed over 2,000 mortar and cannon rounds at Fort Powell, slightly wounding five men and killing one.
In the end, the protracted siege would be broken by four big boxes full of air.
Confederate engineers had been trying to get the heavily armored C.S.S. Tennessee over a sand bar in upper
Mobile Bay so that she could join the fight. They had removed all the cannons and ammunition from the ship
but still could not clear the 14-foot depth of the Dog River bar, made shallower still by northerly winds.
Finally the engineers built four giant wooden boxes, attached them to the Tennessee's hull beneath the
waterline, then pumped them full of air, making the Tennessee just buoyant enough so she could steam into
the lower bay.
On the morning of March 1st the Tennessee lumbered into view near Fort Powell. Farragut immediately
ordered his more lightly armored fleet back to their home bases. The Confederate brass was so delighted
with the outcome they sent Lt. Col. Williams home to Mobile for several weeks of vacation.
The first Battle of Mobile Bay was a rare case of the North fleeing their position because they
suddenly found themselves outgunned. Farragut learned his lesson, and when he returned in August
he had 18 vessels and 5,500 men to the South's 4 vessels, including the Tennessee, and 1,500 men.
And the North barely won that engagement, suffering nine times as many casualties.
Thank God the Union somehow managed to win the Civil War.
And thank God for Mobilians like Sidney Henson Schell.
A maritime attorney by trade and an avid scuba diver and naval historian by avocation, Schell plumbed the
depths of Mobile Bay history in his spare time, helping to locate and survey Civil War shipwrecks including
the C.S.S. Huntsville and Tuscaloosa. He served five terms as chairman of the History Museum of Mobile. He
self-published two books, "Fort Powell and the Civil War" and "The Continental Navy on the Gulf Coast," both
available at Amazon.com.
At the end of his Fort Powell book, Sid describes himself as "a grandfather trying to impart his love of
history to his grandchildren."
Re-enactors gathering at Fort Morgan this weekend owe that man a 21-gun salute.
A recruitment advertisement from the
pages of The Mobile Register, included in Sid Schell's "Fort Powell and the Civil War."
Photo by AL.com from Schell's book
© 2015 AL.com. All rights reserved.
At the time of this piece, Mike Marshall was AL.com Director of Statewide Commentary. Marshall was
executive editor of the Press-Register from 1999 to 2012. You can reach him at [email protected]
**Added thoughts from Marshall's online responses:
Mike Marshall, Jul 31, 2014
"Thank God the Union somehow managed to win the Civil War." I dropped that line in there for this reason:
While I've always admired the pluck of the Confederates, who out-generalled and outfoxed the Union at just
about every turn, I believe a Southern victory would have been disastrous for both sides, for multiple
reasons including the perpetuation of slavery. And according to family lore, one of my paternal forebears
joined Lee's Army at age 16, with the rank of "laborer," and was at Appomattox.